Friday, October 21, 2011

I empathize with feminism. With its different matrices and dimensions, it is the most inclusive philosophy there is. According the Black Feminist scholar Patricia Hill Collins, "paradigms of race, class, and gender [are] interlocking systems of oppression" (1), which become "one overarching structure of domination" (2). This is very similar to the systems/ecological framework where there are different levels, which act in conjunction, and cause cycles that can lead to oppression. These philosophies match up with how I see the world, but I face a certain type of dissonance everyday.

Comedy is my favorite outlet, but it clashes with feminism and the systems/ecological framework constantly. Here is one of my favorite comedians Patrice O'Neal:
This set is incredibly misogynistic, yet I love it. Anything he really says makes me laugh, but does it come at price? If I believe in feminism, am I hypocrite for liking this? Am I allowed to separate comedy from real life, or does comedy add to the patriarchal oppression of women?

Patrice is just one comic and does not represent comedy as a whole, but comedy itself has problems dealing with women. There really are not enough women comics, and when a women starts off in comedy I believe they are already at a disadvantage because there are already set roles of what type of comic they should be in order to be successful. To be successful, I think they have to be somewhat good-looking, they have to play up their sexuality, and they have to be somewhat shocking (If you try to refute that idea of success, ask yourself if there are women versions of Zach Galifinakis or Brian Posehn). A good example of an up-and-coming women comic who plays right into these limitations is Amy Schumer:
If you can get through that clip of her on the admittedly obnoxious Opie and Anthony radio show, you can see that she adheres to a type of comedy that men would want (in the clip before this one Opie and Anthony talk about how they usually do not like women comics). For a comic, that show is a big deal, and for her to get on there, her act needed to hit those three points that I mentioned before. The gatekeepers that help launch comics like Opie and Anthony, Howard Stern, and all the other late night talk show hosts are all men, which makes comedy ultimately patriarchal. Yet I happen to like Amy Schumer better than other woman comedians who do more low-key and cerebrally funny material like Maria Bamford or Tig Notaro. Is my being aware of these facts enough to excuse myself from falling in line with sexists, or am I implicitly contributing to sexism?

Hopefully newer woman comics like Amy Schumer can become the gatekeepers themselves and provide recognition to other woman comics. This would create competition amongst all stand-up comedians and maybe lead to more of an opportunity for woman to explore and take more risks in the stand-up world.

Source:
Hill Collins, Patricia. "Black Feminist Thought in the Matrix of Domination." Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness, and the Politics of Empowerment. 1990.

3 comments:

  1. Ethan, I think that you're observation about "playing into" sexism is something that everyone has struggled with at one time or another. Just by laughing at the misogynistic comedian, or by realizing that a female comedian is focusing her act towards a male audience is definitely something that makes me question my own standards. When I start dancing and singing to Juveniles "Back that Ass up," am I adhering to male chauvenstic standards/exploiting myself and women in general, especially since I'm totally aware of what the lyrics symbolize? Where do we draw the line in choosing what we listen to or watch that can be interpreted as offensive?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think it's tougher for music because a song like "Back that ass up" is not challenging us to think about ourselves and society whereas a comedian's job is to disarm us. For me, the line is crossed when comedians themselves do not know what their comedy is and what they truly believe. Comedians can draw on their life experiences, but their job is to make us think about how and why they interpret those experiences like they do. If someone is up there just spewing their beliefs with little attention to what they're contributing to the greater dialogue then I think comedy can be dangerous. Maybe sometimes though, we just have to not worry about greater social implications and just enjoy things because they are aesthetically pleasing...like "Back that ass up"

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ethan, I respect your perspective that you brought. I dont know whether or not it is equally sexist to know of the oppression and still be entertained by the comedians job that exploits those oppressed women. I know that when we know something--have learned about the negative impact--it can make it more difficult to go back to life before we were aware.
    This is a great example. It appears to me it would be easier to continue watching those comedians if I was unaware of the negative messages they were sending.
    This seems to be a straightforward reaction--dont watch the comedians-- but a murky response because there is still parts that are enjoyable.

    ReplyDelete